AllyRxAllyRx
Reviews
Therapies
  • GLP-1 & Weight Loss
  • Longevity
  • TRT & Men's Health
  • Hair loss
  • Sexual Health
  • Women's HRT
  • Skin Care
View rankings
ComparisonsArticlesStates

NewSelf vs Peter MD

NewSelf logo

NewSelf

2.8
(11)
View pricing
Peter MD logo

Peter MD

4.4
(5)
View pricing

NewSelf editorial score

allyRxTested

Tested and reviewed by our experts

68

out of 100

Pricing
18/25
Quality
14/20
Onboarding
11/15
Medication Options
9/15
Shipping & Fulfillment
7/10
Customer Support
6/10
Usability & Experience
3/5

Peter MD editorial score

allyRxTested

Tested and reviewed by our experts

85

out of 100

Pricing
21/25
Quality
17/20
Onboarding
13/15
Medication Options
12/15
Shipping & Fulfillment
9/10
Customer Support
8/10
Usability & Experience
5/5

NewSelf user rating

Based on 11 user reviews

2.8
Positive36%
Neutral36%
Negative27%

Peter MD user rating

Based on 5 user reviews

4.4
Positive100%
Neutral0%
Negative0%

NewSelf Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Clear headline pricing: $199 semaglutide, $449 tirzepatide (compounded)
  • Publishes partner pharmacies and doctor network
  • In‑stock signaling and free overnight shipping when available

Cons

  • Three‑month commitment with early‑cancellation charges
  • Multiple fees in fine print ($99 admin, $199 chargeback, $150 reship)
  • Site inconsistencies (e.g., “cancel anytime” vs. commitment terms)

Peter MD Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Named state-licensed partner pharmacies disclosed
  • Standard shipping included with signature and tracking

Cons

  • Price variance across product pages and plans

Pricing

18/25

NewSelf promotes $199 semaglutide and $449 tirzepatide memberships with one price across dose tiers, making high dose maintenance budgets predictable. The tradeoff is a three month commitment, $99 to $199 cancellation fees, and reship charges that can erase savings if plans change.

Pricing

21/25

Peter MD lists multiple GLP 1 price points with supplies and shipping included, but promotions and tiers vary by page. Double check whether your plan locks in medication pricing at higher doses so you are not surprised mid titration.

Quality

14/20

Named pharmacy partners and a LegitScript certification show a focus on compliance, and safety pages echo labeled GLP 1 risks. Ask for batch documentation and clarify whether your pharmacy is 503A or 503B before starting so quality expectations stay aligned.

Quality

17/20

Licensed clinicians, HIPAA compliant visits, and disclosed pharmacy partners with signature requirements support strong handling. Ask about lab cadence and pharmacy details before you escalate doses to keep oversight tight.

Onboarding

11/15

The intake, provider review, and promised 72 hour shipping cadence make the journey feel fast, and you can request a different pharmacy if you coordinate ahead. Manage expectations because clinicians still control dose changes and fulfillment can slow when supply tightens.

Onboarding

13/15

The program lets you choose a plan, complete a virtual consult, and receive scripted refills quickly, with lab uploads helping you move faster. Prepare ID and health history so the clinician can approve without needing extra rounds of questions.

Medication Options

9/15

NewSelf concentrates on compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide and does not support brand insurance routes, so the offer suits patients who want flat cost injectables without extra menu complexity. If you need oral options or branded pens, consider a second clinic.

Medication Options

12/15

Peter MD covers compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide with vitamin B blends plus a broader catalog for TRT, hair, sexual health, and women's HRT. It is a practical one stop shop for well known options even if it does not chase emerging therapies.

Shipping & Fulfillment

7/10

Free overnight shipping with cold chain packaging keeps meds protected, yet the seven day issue window and reship fees make it important to inspect packages immediately. Track deliveries closely and update addresses before pharmacy processing begins.

Shipping & Fulfillment

9/10

Standard shipping is included, signature is required, and expedited upgrades are available, with pharmacy addresses published for transparency. Watch for the tracking email so you can accept cold chain deliveries promptly.

Customer Support

6/10

Phone numbers, email, and 24 hour messaging give you multiple touchpoints, and many public reviews mention quick help. Finance policies are strict, so keep receipts, document calls, and handle disputes quickly if a charge looks wrong.

Customer Support

8/10

Weekday phone and text support respond quickly and memberships include unlimited consults, so both logistics and clinical questions find a home. Clarify after hours guidance for injectables to avoid weekend uncertainty.

Usability & Experience

3/5

Bold price tiles, safety links, and a modern intake make the site easy to use, though marketing copy occasionally conflicts with policy language. Read the terms carefully so the slick UI and the commitment rules stay in sync.

Usability & Experience

5/5

The site is fast with clear program pages and a portal that centralizes refills, cancellations, and lab requests. Make sure the checkout matches the pricing you saw earlier, since tiers are shown in several formats.

Therapy Specializations

NewSelf

GLP-1 & Weight Loss

Peter MD

GLP-1 & Weight Loss

Medications Offered

NewSelf

  • Semaglutide

    $199 / month

    Free overnight shipping when in stock; policy windows apply.

  • Tirzepatide

    $449 / month

    Free overnight shipping when in stock; policy windows apply.

Peter MD

Medication list not available.

AllyRx

Independent telehealth research for confident care decisions

We benchmark digital health providers, pricing, and clinical programs so you can compare options with clarity. Every review is grounded in medical sourcing, patient outcomes, and transparent scoring.

See how we compare providers

Explore AllyRx

  • Home
  • Provider Reviews
  • Medication Comparisons
  • Articles & Research

Telehealth Programs

  • GLP-1 Weight Loss
  • Hormone & TRT
  • Women's Health
  • Sexual Health

Email us anytime:

info@allyrx.net

AllyRx is editorially independent. We never accept sponsored placements or referral fees in our scoring.

© 2026 AllyRx. All rights reserved.

Independent research. No sponsored content.