NewSelf vs Peter MD

Provider comparison details

NewSelf logo

NewSelf

2.7
(12 approved)
Read review
Peter MD logo

Peter MD

4.4
(5 approved)
Read review

NewSelf editorial score

Tested and reviewed by our experts

68

out of 100

Pricing
18/25
Quality
14/20
Onboarding
11/15
Medication Options
9/15
Shipping & Fulfillment
7/10
Customer Support
6/10
Usability & Experience
3/5

Peter MD editorial score

Tested and reviewed by our experts

85

out of 100

Pricing
21/25. Highlighted category
Quality
17/20. Highlighted category
Onboarding
13/15. Highlighted category
Medication Options
12/15. Highlighted category
Shipping & Fulfillment
9/10. Highlighted category
Customer Support
8/10. Highlighted category
Usability & Experience
5/5. Highlighted category

NewSelf user rating

Based on 12 approved user reviews

2.7
Positive33%
Neutral33%
Negative33%

Peter MD user rating

Based on 5 approved user reviews

4.4
Positive100%
Neutral0%
Negative0%

NewSelf Pros and Cons

Pros

  • No separate membership fee is advertised
  • Semaglutide and tirzepatide are marketed at one price across dose tiers
  • Clinician review and overnight cold shipping are included
  • Partner medical and pharmacy entities are publicly named

Cons

  • Multiple public pages show conflicting prices for the same treatments
  • GLP-1 plans carry a three-month commitment despite monthly billing
  • Refunds narrow sharply after the medical consultation
  • Prescription-change, reship, early-cancellation, and dispute-related fees can apply

Peter MD Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Wide treatment menu within one telehealth platform
  • Published starting prices for several popular programs
  • Virtual clinician consultation and direct home delivery
  • Clear public auto-renewal and damaged-product rules

Cons

  • Lowest advertised rates may depend on plan length or prepayment
  • Several offerings are compounded and are not FDA-approved
  • State limits and total program costs are not uniform across every treatment page

Pricing

18/25

Potentially low flat-dose prices, undermined by several conflicting public displays.

Pricing

21/25

Published starting rates are helpful, but the lowest figures can depend on longer plan terms and changing promotions.

Quality

14/20

Independent clinician and pharmacy partners are named, with compounded-drug caveats remaining essential.

Quality

17/20

Licensed-provider evaluation is built into the process; compounded products still require pharmacy and monitoring questions.

Onboarding

11/15

A short remote intake is convenient, but refund rights narrow after the consultation.

Onboarding

13/15

Assessment, virtual consultation, and home delivery create a simple path, with labs varying by treatment.

Medication Options

9/15

The program focuses on two compounded injection pathways with added ingredients.

Medication Options

12/15

The catalog is broad across hormones, weight management, hair loss, sexual health, labs, and longevity.

Shipping & Fulfillment

7/10

Cold shipping is included, while delivery promises and replacement rules need confirmation.

Shipping & Fulfillment

9/10

Direct discreet shipping is integrated, while routine medication returns are restricted after receipt.

Customer Support

6/10

Phone, email, portal, and care access are advertised without response-time guarantees.

Customer Support

8/10

Customer and clinician contact routes are available, with a firm advance-cancellation deadline for renewals.

Usability & Experience

3/5

The flow is simple but stale and duplicate content weakens trust.

Usability & Experience

5/5

Programs are easy to find by goal, though varied promotions and plan lengths complicate total-cost comparison.

Therapy Specializations

NewSelf

GLP-1 & Weight Loss

Peter MD

GLP-1 & Weight Loss

Explore more comparisons

Discover other matchups featuring these providers plus trending comparisons across AllyRx.

GobyMeds logo

GobyMeds

3.83 (6)
vs
NewSelf logo

NewSelf

2.67 (12)
4.4
Pricing
3.6
4.5
Quality
3.5
4.7
Onboarding
3.7
3.5
Support
3
Eden Health logo

Eden Health

3.40 (5)
vs
Ro logo

Ro

4.00 (10)
4.2
Pricing
4.2
3.5
Quality
4.3
4.3
Onboarding
4.3
4
Support
3.5
Willow logo

Willow

3.89 (9)
vs
LumiMeds logo

LumiMeds

4.13 (8)
4.4
Pricing
4.4
3.5
Quality
3.3
4.7
Onboarding
3.7
3.5
Support
4
Mochi Health logo

Mochi Health

4.11 (9)
vs
Orderly Meds logo

Orderly Meds

3.50 (8)
4.2
Pricing
4
3.3
Quality
3
4
Onboarding
4
2
Support
3
Pomegranate Health logo

Pomegranate Health

3.40 (5)
vs
Sprout Health logo

Sprout Health

4.40 (5)
4.4
Pricing
4.4
4.3
Quality
2
4
Onboarding
4
3.5
Support
3.5
Sesame Care logo

Sesame Care

3.82 (11)
vs
Hims logo

Hims

4.09 (11)
4
Pricing
4
3.8
Quality
4
4.7
Onboarding
4.3
3.5
Support
3.5
Brello Health logo

Brello Health

3.88 (8)
vs
Amble logo

Amble

4.00 (12)
4.4
Pricing
4
4.3
Quality
3.5
4
Onboarding
4.3
3
Support
3.5
Eden Health logo

Eden Health

3.40 (5)
vs
Hims logo

Hims

4.09 (11)
4.2
Pricing
4
3.5
Quality
4
4.3
Onboarding
4.3
4
Support
3.5