AllyRxAllyRx
Reviews
Therapies
  • GLP-1 & Weight Loss
  • Longevity
  • TRT & Men's Health
  • Hair loss
  • Sexual Health
  • Women's HRT
  • Skin Care
View rankings
ComparisonsArticlesStates

Effecty vs Hims

Effecty logo

Effecty

4.0
(6)
View pricing
Hims logo

Hims

4.1
(11)
View pricing

Effecty editorial score

allyRxTested

Tested and reviewed by our experts

85

out of 100

Pricing
23/25
Quality
16/20
Onboarding
13/15
Medication Options
13/15
Shipping & Fulfillment
8/10
Customer Support
8/10
Usability & Experience
4/5

Hims editorial score

allyRxTested

Tested and reviewed by our experts

81

out of 100

Pricing
20/25
Quality
16/20
Onboarding
13/15
Medication Options
13/15
Shipping & Fulfillment
8/10
Customer Support
7/10
Usability & Experience
4/5

Effecty user rating

Based on 6 user reviews

4.0
Positive100%
Neutral0%
Negative0%

Hims user rating

Based on 11 user reviews

4.1
Positive91%
Neutral9%
Negative0%

Effecty Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Works with state licensed compounding pharmacies for fulfillment
  • Free expedited two day shipping after the prescription is filled

Cons

  • Shipping excluded in five states for some therapies

Hims Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Wide men’s catalog
  • Streamlined online onboarding
  • At-home labs
  • Statewide coverage

Cons

  • “As low as” prices usually require 6–12‑month prepayment;
  • Availability varies by state.
  • 24–72 hour response times.

Pricing

23/25

Effecty posts monthly prices on every product card and ties them to the supply window so costs are clear before checkout. Free expedited shipping is included, but payment is authorized upfront and refunds only apply if you cancel before a shipment goes out.

Pricing

20/25

Hims lists starting prices for compounded semaglutide at $199 and branded pens near $1,799 so the cost difference is visible before checkout. Multi month bundles lower the first month yet refunds end once the pharmacy begins filling an order, so plan accordingly.

Quality

16/20

Licensed clinicians review each case, work with U.S. partner pharmacies, and include direct provider messaging in the plan. Because specific pharmacy names and batch details are not public, ask for that information when you onboard and keep labs handy.

Quality

16/20

Board certified clinicians manage titration with CLIA grade labs and USP aligned compounding partners, and safety warnings appear across product pages. Continue to review certificates and ask about pharmacy sourcing whenever you move to a higher dose.

Onboarding

13/15

The questionnaire and telehealth visit move quickly, and most prescriptions ship within five to seven business days with two day delivery once a label is printed. Eligibility prompts and payment holds are handled at checkout, which lowers the chance of surprises later.

Onboarding

13/15

The intake, photo ID upload, and telehealth approval can wrap in a day, and most refills leave the pharmacy within a business day. Keep in mind that controlled medications still require synchronous visits and brand prior authorizations can add a few weeks.

Medication Options

13/15

Effecty carries compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide, branded Wegovy and Ozempic, metformin, enclomiphene based TRT, and multiple finasteride combinations, covering core needs across weight, hormone, and hair programs. Dose ranges follow standard titrations even if every concentration is not exposed on site.

Medication Options

13/15

Hims covers a wide portfolio from GLP 1 injectables to ED chewables, SSRIs, dermatology kits, and enclomiphene based TRT so men can coordinate multiple needs under one roof. Compounded blends fill gaps during shortages even though FDA review does not extend to those formulations.

Shipping & Fulfillment

8/10

After approval, orders ship free via expedited service and usually land within two days, though state coverage varies by therapy so confirm your ZIP during intake. Track deliveries promptly because cold chain and storage guidance arrive with the package.

Shipping & Fulfillment

8/10

Prescriptions typically ship within one to two business days in discreet packaging with a $5 handling fee, and cold chain GLP 1 orders arrive with temperature monitors. There is no expedited upgrade, so plan ahead if you need a rush refill or prefer local pickup.

Customer Support

8/10

You can message your prescribing provider, email support, and cancel by request, which keeps account management simple. There is no live chat, so rely on the portal for history and follow up quickly if you need adjustments.

Customer Support

7/10

Secure messaging with clinicians, pharmacy hotlines, and scheduled consults keep most questions covered, but there is no always on live chat or phone triage. Use the portal for a paper trail and escalate by phone if asynchronous replies slow down.

Usability & Experience

4/5

Pricing sits on each tile, the intake is linear, and FAQs explain billing holds and card charges in plain language, making the experience feel modern. Adding a persistent state coverage banner and naming partner pharmacies would improve transparency even more.

Usability & Experience

4/5

The dashboard organizes refills, labs, and trackers cleanly and reminds you when forms or vitals are due. Pricing copy sometimes conflicts with checkout totals, so review the order summary before you confirm payment.

Therapy Specializations

Effecty

GLP-1 & Weight LossLongevityWomen's HRT

Hims

GLP-1 & Weight LossHair lossSexual HealthTRT & Men's Health
AllyRx

Independent telehealth research for confident care decisions

We benchmark digital health providers, pricing, and clinical programs so you can compare options with clarity. Every review is grounded in medical sourcing, patient outcomes, and transparent scoring.

See how we compare providers

Explore AllyRx

  • Home
  • Provider Reviews
  • Medication Comparisons
  • Articles & Research

Telehealth Programs

  • GLP-1 Weight Loss
  • Hormone & TRT
  • Women's Health
  • Sexual Health

Email us anytime:

info@allyrx.net

AllyRx is editorially independent. We never accept sponsored placements or referral fees in our scoring.

© 2026 AllyRx. All rights reserved.

Independent research. No sponsored content.